Kashmiri Pandits' Exile not a lesser tragedy: Vishal Bhardwaj
Jan 22,2015
Jaipur, Jan 22 (IANS) Filmmaker Vishal Bhardwaj, who excluded the representation of Kashmiri Pandits in his film "Haider", Thursday said he was never "insensitive" towards the mass exodus that made the majority of the community "refugees" in their own country.
Bhardwaj's Indian adaptation of Shakespeare's "Hamlet" was the final film of his trilogy, along with "Maqbool" and "Omkara", adapted from the plays "Macbeth" and "Othello" respectively.
The Shahid Kapoor-starrer, however, got embroiled in a post-release controversy where many blamed Bhardwaj for "showing only one side of Kashmir".
"The story of Kashmiri Pandits is not a less tragedy at all. But cinema gives you a choice and it was my choice to make a movie on this subject. Basically, the topic didn't allow me to focus on that tragedy," Bharadwaj said at a session titled "Hamlet's Dilemma" at the ongoing Jaipur Literature Festival.
"I am not insensitive towards them because overnight so many people became refugees in their own country," he said.
It seemed the 49-year-old filmmaker was ready for this question to be thrown at him and sounded a bit irked when asked the same.
But he had come prepared with a question which he threw at the audience.
"Why didn't you ask the same question to Vidhu Vinod Chopra? He too had made 'Mission Kashmir'. He had the power and he was from the same community, yet he didn't. I might make a movie whenever I feel like and show their side as well," he added.
The idea of making "Hamlet" against the backdrop of "Kashmir" had struck Bhardwaj when he read journalist-author Basharat Peer's "Curfewed Night", an account of the Kashmir conflict and he decided to rope in Peer for the script.
Peer, who was also present at the session, made an important point that substantiated the "absence" of Kashmiri Pandits from the film.
"The book is based in 1995 and we had to have situations and events that could fit into the story of Hamlet. And frankly I could have done 'tokenism' to tell their story, but this is not a quota system," he said.
"It is a great human shame. It is the shame on the nation who haven't made a film on the plight of Kashmiri Pandits. We were making a film and not a visual documentary on Kashmir," he added.
The heated debate ended with the large gathering cheering and supporting the expression of cinema and celebration of Shakespeare.
Top Stories
'Jan Nayagan' Movie Review: Vijay's Final Film Is Overshadowed by Politics, 3-Hour Runtime Tests Patience
Jul 23,2026
Vijay's much-awaited farewell film, Jan Nayagan, arrives with massive expectations, marking the superstar's final appearance on the big screen before his full-time political journey. While fans hoped for an unforgettable send-off, director H. Vinoth delivers a film where political messag
Jantar Mantar Protest: From R. Madhavan to Alia Bhatt, Celebrities Rally Behind Students; Here's What They Said
Jul 23,2026
The nationwide outrage over the alleged NEET paper leak has intensified, with thousands of students staging protests at Delhi's Jantar Mantar and demonstrations spreading across Mumbai and several other cities. Protesters are demanding a transparent investigation into the examination cont
Vijay's 'Jana Nayagan' Creates Box Office Storm: Two Major Tamil Films Postponed as Fans Celebrate Thalapathy's Final Movie
Jul 16,2026
The excitement surrounding Thalapathy Vijay's highly anticipated film 'Jana Nayagan' has reached unprecedented levels ahead of its July 23, 2026 release. Widely believed to be Vijay's final film before entering full-time politics, the movie has prompted two Tamil filmmakers to postpone
Salman Khan’s New House Approved: Is He Finally Leaving Galaxy Apartments After 52 Years?
Jun 30,2026
Rumours about Salman Khan leaving his iconic Galaxy Apartments residence have been making headlines after reports claimed the Bollywood superstar was preparing to move into a new luxury home in Bandra. However, the reality is quite different. While the Khan family's sea-facing Bandra prop
Security Breach Involving Arbaaz Khan: Intruder Jumps Into Actor’s Car, Removed by Bouncer
Jun 17,2026
Actor Arbaaz Khan recently found himself at the center of a security scare during a public event in Kolkata. A video from the incident has gone viral on social media, showing an unidentified man allegedly forcing his way into the actor's car as he was leaving the venue.The unexpected inci
‘Happy Birthday to the Queen’: Priyanka Chopra Shares Special Birthday Wish for Mother Madhu Chopra
Jun 17,2026
Global star Priyanka Chopra Jonas melted hearts on social media after sharing a special birthday message for her mother, Dr. Madhu Chopra. The actress took to Instagram Stories to celebrate her mother's birthday and expressed gratitude for her constant guidance and support.The heartfelt p
Kangana Ranaut Breaks Silence on ‘Don 3’ Controversy, Says ‘Ranveer Singh Is Being Targeted After Dhurandhar’
Jun 12,2026
Bollywood actress and politician Kangana Ranaut has once again sparked discussion with her comments on the controversy surrounding Ranveer Singh and his reported exit from Don 3. Speaking in a recent interview, Kangana suggested that Ranveer may have been unfairly targeted following the su
Anupam Kher Scolds David Dhawan Over Retirement Rumors: "Who Are You to Decide..."
Jun 04,2026
Veteran Bollywood filmmaker David Dhawan has returned to the director’s chair after a gap of six years. However, what has surprised fans even more is his announcement that his upcoming film Yeh Jawani Hai Deewani will reportedly be his final directorial venture before retirement.But
Entertainment News
Kangana Ranaut Breaks Silence
Jun 12,2026
Anupam Kher Scolds David Dhawa
Jun 04,2026
'Bad breath from her mouth...'
Jun 03,2026
Kangana Ranaut Recalls 26/11 M
Jun 03,2026
Bobby Deol Reveals Who Can Pla
Jun 02,2026