Kashmiri Pandits' Exile not a lesser tragedy: Vishal Bhardwaj
Jan 22,2015
Jaipur, Jan 22 (IANS) Filmmaker Vishal Bhardwaj, who excluded the representation of Kashmiri Pandits in his film "Haider", Thursday said he was never "insensitive" towards the mass exodus that made the majority of the community "refugees" in their own country.
Bhardwaj's Indian adaptation of Shakespeare's "Hamlet" was the final film of his trilogy, along with "Maqbool" and "Omkara", adapted from the plays "Macbeth" and "Othello" respectively.
The Shahid Kapoor-starrer, however, got embroiled in a post-release controversy where many blamed Bhardwaj for "showing only one side of Kashmir".
"The story of Kashmiri Pandits is not a less tragedy at all. But cinema gives you a choice and it was my choice to make a movie on this subject. Basically, the topic didn't allow me to focus on that tragedy," Bharadwaj said at a session titled "Hamlet's Dilemma" at the ongoing Jaipur Literature Festival.
"I am not insensitive towards them because overnight so many people became refugees in their own country," he said.
It seemed the 49-year-old filmmaker was ready for this question to be thrown at him and sounded a bit irked when asked the same.
But he had come prepared with a question which he threw at the audience.
"Why didn't you ask the same question to Vidhu Vinod Chopra? He too had made 'Mission Kashmir'. He had the power and he was from the same community, yet he didn't. I might make a movie whenever I feel like and show their side as well," he added.
The idea of making "Hamlet" against the backdrop of "Kashmir" had struck Bhardwaj when he read journalist-author Basharat Peer's "Curfewed Night", an account of the Kashmir conflict and he decided to rope in Peer for the script.
Peer, who was also present at the session, made an important point that substantiated the "absence" of Kashmiri Pandits from the film.
"The book is based in 1995 and we had to have situations and events that could fit into the story of Hamlet. And frankly I could have done 'tokenism' to tell their story, but this is not a quota system," he said.
"It is a great human shame. It is the shame on the nation who haven't made a film on the plight of Kashmiri Pandits. We were making a film and not a visual documentary on Kashmir," he added.
The heated debate ended with the large gathering cheering and supporting the expression of cinema and celebration of Shakespeare.
Top Stories
King vs. Avengers: Doomsday – Shah Rukh Khan says "The father will come first," anticipating a Christmas box office clash.
Sep 15,2026
Shah Rukh Khan has once again shown why he is known as Bollywood’s ‘King Khan’. During his latest #AskSRK session on X, the superstar gave a witty response when a fan asked him about the much-discussed box-office clash between his upcoming film King and Marvel Studios&rsq
Salman Khan’s Ganesh Chaturthi Look Goes Viral: Tilak and Angavastram Steal the Show
Sep 15,2026
Salman Khan's appearance at the Ambani family's Ganesh Chaturthi celebration has become a talking point on social media. A video showing the Bollywood superstar offering prayers to Lord Ganpati at Antilia has gone viral, with fans praising his traditional festive appearance and the momen
Emraan Hashmi’s Iconic Heartbreak Song: Pakistani Singer Who Shot to Fame With This Rock Hit
Aug 18,2026
Emraan Hashmi has long been associated with memorable romantic and heartbreak songs. Over the years, the music of his films has produced several tracks that continue to feature prominently on listeners’ playlists.One such song is “Lambi Judai” from the 2008 film J
Shatrughan Sinha on Sonakshi Sinha Trolling: Accuses BJP IT Cell, Opens Up on Her Political Entry
Aug 18,2026
Veteran actor and Trinamool Congress (TMC) leader Shatrughan Sinha has spoken out over the social media trolling faced by his daughter, actor Sonakshi Sinha.In an interview with ABP News, Shatrughan addressed criticism of Sonakshi's public support for student protests and also res
Batwara 1947 Review: Sunny Deol Shines in a Powerful and Emotional Partition Drama
Aug 14,2026
Batwara 1947 Movie Review: When director Rajkumar Santoshi and Sunny Deol reunite, expectations are bound to be high. After memorable collaborations such as Ghayal, Damini and Ghatak, the duo returns with Batwara 1947, a Partition-era drama that takes a noticeably different route.R
‘Ramayana’: ‘Mahabharat’ Actor Gajendra Chauhan Reacts to Ranbir Kapoor’s Trailer, “I Wasn’t Impressed”
Aug 12,2026
Nitesh Tiwari's much-awaited ‘Ramayana’ has generated considerable buzz following the release of its trailer. While the trailer has received mixed reactions, actor Gajendra Chauhan, best known for playing Yudhishthira in B.R. Chopra's iconic Mahabharat, has now shared his opi
Urmila Matondkar’s Ex-Husband Mohsin Akhtar Mir Marries Again; Actress Takes a Dig at Second Wedding
Aug 12,2026
Urmila Matondkar is once again making headlines, this time because of a cryptic social media post following a post shared by her ex-husband Mohsin Akhtar Mir about his second wife, Nida Bhat.The actress, who generally keeps her personal life private, shared a message on Instagram that quic
Munna Bhaiya Returns in ‘Mirzapur: The Movie’: Divyenndu Says, “It Was a Mistake, I Am Immortal”
Aug 12,2026
Fans are eagerly awaiting ‘Mirzapur: The Movie’, and one of the biggest talking points is Divyenndu’s return as Munna Bhaiya. The character died in the second season of the popular series, making his comeback one of the film’s biggest surprises.Divyenndu on Munna Bh
Entertainment News
Munna Bhaiya Returns in ‘Mir
Aug 12,2026
Urmila Matondkar’s Ex-Husban
Aug 12,2026
Suniel Shetty Birthday: Ajay D
Aug 11,2026
Pradeep Rawat Funeral: Aamir K
Aug 05,2026
Nikita Rawal on Ranbir Kapoor
Aug 05,2026