In Benedetta, Paul Verhoeven tells the forbidden love story of two nuns while confronting gender bias in 17th century Italy

Dec 20,2021

But not just any nunnery … oh no, this one shall contain erotic secrets and sexy scandals! Nudity! Well-lit cunnilingus! Dildo carving! Ecstatic moaning! And of course, the notorious centuries-old intolerance of the Catholic church which hypocritically encourages all manner of sexual subterfuge and perversion. Not that lesbianism is perverse: far from it! But this medieval-era sex romp masquerading as a historical drama suggests that even when women boldly go after what they want, their sexual uvirrges should still be punishable by death. “All witchcraft stems from carnal desire, which is in women insatiable,” or so said those two German guys who wrote the Malleus Maleficarum, the famous 15th-century witch-hunting manual.

Based on Judith Brown’s 1986 book Immodest Acts: The Life of a Lesbian Nun in Renaissance Italy, director Paul Verhoeven’s latest film is at times a fairly straightforward period piece. Set in Tuscany, most of the action takes place within the walls of a convent dedicated to Saint Mary. Young Benedetta arrives at the convent at age nine. She’s from a modest merchant’s family, and various strange events have convinced her village that she has unusual powers of spiritual insight. Initially traumatized by the austere living conditions of the convent, she soon becomes a model initiate, but her overeager demeanor tends to annoy the strict abbess Sister Felicita (Charlotte Rampling, in a subdued but juicy role). In her late 20s, Benedetta (Virginie Efira) meets a novitiate who has come to the convent to escape her father’s abuse. Bartolomea (Daphne Patakia) is immodest and earthy and, sensing Benedetta’s curiosity, she sets about to willfully seduce her. Normally such exploits would be severely punished, but Benedetta understands that her mystical visions and spontaneous episodes of stigmata give her leverage within the abbey as well as beyond its walls. The two nuns pursue their erotic delights with increasing enthusiasm, and the walls of the convent can barely contain their screams of joy.

In the context of this story arc of sexual awakening, the film’s heritage tone is established firmly, but gradually we begin to see odd moments of anachronism, such as snatches of contemporary music along with modern looking makeup and bleached hair. Normally I’d chalk that up to flawed production design, but then it occurred to me that the flashes of modernity in the film’s aesthetic were intended to enhance the rather prurient scenes that dominate the film’s narrative arc. I dunno what Verhoeven’s childhood was like, but I am guessing his adolescence was a time of richly detailed sexual fantasies that dovetailed with his evolving opinion of the church. I mean, we can’t really control our kinks, right? They arise out of a combination of factors, including what pleases us, what traumatizes us, what we fear, what we desire, what is available to us, and what’s forbidden to us. Sexual pleasure in almost every form has been forbidden and abhorred by the Catholic church. And it’s no secret that the institution is rife with sexual abuse scandals and cover-ups.

Is Verhoeven trying to exorcise demons of a frustrated or traumatic adolescence by making this film a bit more raunchy than it needs to be, but perhaps not as raunchy as it ought to be? (One wonders, for example, what bad boy fantasist Ken Russell might have done with this material.) Rather disappointingly, but perhaps not surprisingly, the expressions of lesbian eroticism in Benedetta are very obviously depicted for the male gaze. If there’s any kind of feminist message intended here, it’s undermined by the manipulative machinations of nearly every female character, and the rather unimaginative and somewhat crude portrayal of sexuality.

Still, the film is entertaining enough, with good performances all around. The story of a nun who utilizes her sexual wiles and powers of persuasion to become a sort of minor celebrity feels like a familiar conceit. It sets up Benedetta’s vilification rather well, paralleling the witch craze of medieval Europe, when women were accused of lechery and heresy in equal measure. But, as news of the scandalous behavior in this Tuscan abbey reaches Florence, the Nuncio is dispatched to investigate. Lambert Wilson is excellent as the conceited and snobbish cleric, who thinks the nuns of the abbey are little better than filthy guttersnipes. His feigned shock and revulsion belies his savvy sadism and, when Benedetta is put on trial, it all starts to feel a bit contrived, cinematically speaking. Even the arrival of the frightening specter of bubonic plague feels slightly ridiculous at times, though it does lend a tinge of topical urgency to this period piece. The film’s final message of human frailty is a stark reminder of our own ongoing turbulence, where performative moral outrage continues to trump the mitigation of real human crises that are rending our social fabric.

Tags:

Lambert Wilson Lambert Wilson in news news about Lambert Wilson

Shah Rukh Khan's 'King' song leaked online? King Khan seen kissing Deepika; users react.

Dec 19,2025

It was claimed that the entire song from the film 'King' had been leaked on social media. The video allegedly showed Shah Rukh Khan romancing Deepika Padukone and even kissing her. Is this song truly from the film 'King'? And what was the reaction of Shah Rukh Khan's fans to this song

Happy Patel Trailer: This duo from Aamir Khan's film is back again with DK Bose; will this mark Imran Khan's comeback?

Dec 19,2025

The trailer for Happy Patel: Dangerous Spy, directed by and starring Vir Das, has been released. This fun announcement has generated considerable excitement for the film, which is set to release in January 2026. The film also marks the comeback of Imran Khan. A Fun Announcem

Esha Deol returned to work after her father Dharmendra's death, saying, "Don't misunderstand me as a daughter."

Dec 19,2025

The entire Bollywood industry, including fans and the Deol family, is still reeling from the death of veteran actor Dharmendra. Recently, his son Sunny Deol attended the teaser launch of his upcoming film Border 2, where he was visibly emotional. Now, following Sunny, Esha Deol has also re

After watching Dhurandhar, Ram Gopal Varma gave his review, saying, "This is a warning for everyone."

Dec 19,2025

While the film "Dhurandhar" is receiving widespread acclaim everywhere, how could filmmaker Ram Gopal Varma be left behind? Ram Gopal Varma also showered immense praise on the Ranveer Singh and Akshaye Khanna starrer "Dhurandhar." He called the film, directed by Aditya Dhar, an unprecedented a

Two actresses have joined Shahid Kapoor's O Romeo, and these beauties are unmatched in terms of hotness.

Dec 18,2025

Actor Shahid Kapoor will kick off the new year with his favorite filmmaker, Vishal Bhardwaj. Their upcoming film, O Romeo, has been the subject of much discussion for a long time, with various reports surfacing about the film's shooting and cast.Now, news is circulating that two famous Bo

Ranveer's fans targeted Rishab Shetty over the Kantara controversy, saying, "If the deities were angry, then why was the film a blockbuster hit?"

Dec 16,2025

Ranveer Singh is currently enjoying the success of his film 'Dhruva'. The film is doing exceptionally well at the box office. Meanwhile, a controversy involving Ranveer and 'Kantara' has resurfaced. Ranveer had faced criticism for mimicking Rishab Shetty's character from 'Kantara Cha

Shraddha Kapoor lashed out at Dhurandhar's enemies, 'Stree' exposed Bollywood's hypocrisy, and she supported Yami Gautam!

Dec 16,2025

Filmmaker Aditya Dhar's film Dhurandhar is raking in massive profits at the box office, and every character in the film is being discussed on social media. It has received immense praise from both audiences and celebrities. This spy thriller has already crossed the ?500 crore mark worldwi

Kriti Sanon gave an update on 'Cocktail 2', saying, 'The film is being made at the right time'; she also commented on Shahid and Rashmika.

Dec 15,2025

Kriti Sanon is currently one of the leading actresses in the industry. She is consistently part of big films. Her recently released film, 'Tere Ishq Mein', also crossed the 100 crore mark at the box office. The actress is currently busy shooting for her upcoming film, 'Cocktail 2'. Mea